-- Advertisement --

Bush's Legacy

Does Obama control George W. Bush's historical future?

Critics and pundits alike are already penning the pages of history. 

One potential title?  "Bush: A Miserable Failure."

Nearly 70% of the United States approves of Obama's work so far and Liberals are especially ecstatic over the change in administration.  Mr. Obama has already brought heady, contentious issues to the forefront in his new presidency.  While Obama is making a clear case that the country is now in the right hands, and with the lefties agreeing wholeheartedly, there is another vigorous (albeit quiet) supporter of the newly elected President.  George W. Bush.

He has to be...his future history is currently being written in the halls of his former home.

Mr. Bush’s legacy seems to be in jeopardy of being catalogued as one of the worst of all time, right up there with Herbert Hoover’s.  Under his administration, including a bull-headed push into a unilateral Iraq war, based on a false conclusions of possession of Weapons of Mass Destruction and his drastic and elaborate stretching of both the Geneva Convention and Bill of Rights with Guantanamo Bay and secret CIA prisons scattered across the globe and domestic surveillance and, of course, disastrous economic policies still threatening and crippling the economy, Bush's supporters in the vast minority. 

Barack Obama's new direction is already reversing some of these Bush-era policies.  Further, Obama carries the burden of structuring Mr. Bush’s legacy.

Right now, Bush stands to benefit only from his own clear message: We haven’t been attacked since 9/11.  But, wars end.  Recessions rebound.  Policies are forgotten.  Things improve.  If Mr. Obama secures the new, dramatic change he promised to bring to America, it’s not only going to secure his reelection in 2012, it’s going to secure a positive place for Mr. Bush in the history books.

On the other hand, if Mr. Obama falls, so does the former President.  If the 16 month withdrawal from Iraq proceeds as planned and subsequently drives the country into bitter fighting and catastrophic chaos, Bush will face the same public gallows as Obama.  Similarly, if the proposed stimulus plan does nothing to the economy but create a mess of unfinished infrastructure projects, while increasing lines at the welfare, unemployment and food stamp agencies, Mr. Bush will be again disparaged for his initial hand in the downward spiral.  

What do you think about Bush's legacy?

 
COMMENTS & DISCUSSION (35) COMMENTS
richard hummel
Jan. 27, 2009
02:49 PM EST
I'M NOT A BIG SUPPORTER OF PRESIDENT BUSH , but he did keep this country safe

Long Standing Bear Chief
Jan. 27, 2009
02:47 PM EST
I believe George W. Bush was and is a very evil man. His administation must be throughly investigated and chargee with crimes against humanity where it is neccesary and he and his minions or instigators charged and imprisoned where he is found guilty for his and the crims of his fellows who broke the law with him.

The Tree Lady
Jan. 27, 2009
04:31 PM EST
The Bush administration was the most inept, divisive, dishonest, irresponsible, anti-environmental, undemocratic, and corrupt administration in U.S. history. No matter what Obama does or does not do, that will not change. If historians are honest and objective, they will thus write the pages of history.

MAX
Jan. 27, 2009
04:27 PM EST
GEORGE BUSH IS A GOOD MORAL MAN AND WAS DOOMED FROM THE START AND WAS BLAMED FOR EVERYTHING THAT HAPPENED IN THE LAST 8 YEARS. EVEN WITH REPUBLICAN CONTROL OF CONGRESS HE HAD TO FIGHT FOR EVERY JUDGE OR POLICY HE TRIED TO IMPLEMENT. HE ALSO CAME TO THE WHITE HOUSE TRYING TO UNITE BUT THERE WAS NO WAY THE DEMOCRATS WOULD EVER GIVE 1 INCH AND USED THE FILABUSTER ON EVERYTHING THAT CAME ALONG. GEORGE WAS A MAN THAT SAID WHAT HE MEANT AND MEANT WHAT HE SAID AS THE TERROIST SOON FOUND OUT. WHY NOT BLAME SADAM FOR THE IRAQ WAR SINCE HE WAS THE ONE THAT CAUSED THE SITUATION. WHY NOT BLAME THE GOV AND MAYOR OF NO FOR KATRINA. OBAMA DID NOT WASTE ANY TIME WITH AIDING IN THE KILLING OF MILLIONS OF INNOCENT UNBORN BABIES WITH THE HELP OF MY TAX DOLLARS. GOD HELP AMERICA FOR THE NEXT 4 YEARS.

Boudica13
Jan. 27, 2009
04:20 PM EST
I never liked Bush, I believe he stole both elections. I think he is a dictator and I couldn't wait to see him go. For Prez Obama, he has a very hard road ahead of him. And I really hope no one thinks that he will be able to come in and fixed the mess the last 8 years. There is no magic wand here. He needs our help probable more then any other Prez in the last 50-60 years. I'm so proud of my country and I hope the Prez will a lot of help can turn this country around in so very many ways. Plus the idiots, like Rush L. shuts up and find solace in whatever it is he needs to get him through this new day and the following of many others.

Pat
Jan. 27, 2009
04:03 PM EST
To Long Standing Bear Chief: I agree George W has been an evil man. I think he should be investigated. I think Bill Clinton is an evil man and should be investigated. I bet you don't agree with that last part. It is idiots like you that fall for this "Two Party " charade. There is only one party and it's " Big Bear Chief" is Z. Brzinzski. Every President of the last 36 years gets his orders from this evil man.

Janice
Jan. 27, 2009
03:36 PM EST
well, the American people did not look hard enough before electing George W, if they had of, they would have seen that he made a mess of everything he ever attempted to do. I never voted for him becasue he was not right as our leader and i couldnt stand that smirky look on his face and the way he talked or should i say (read) his speeches to the American people. I'm not even sure he believed what he said, so therefore how could he expect us to believe in him. I'm just glad he is finally out of office and I wish him the best.

Jeff Levin
Jan. 27, 2009
03:35 PM EST
He has to be the worst in HISTORY!After 911 he became very paranoid about the vulnerability of our country. Nation wise he destroyed our economic welfare. After bailing out the banks, there was no one in charge to keep track of where the money was going or being spent. Lets hope Obama's bill will be watched more carefully, so that our country can get back on its feet.

Susan
Jan. 27, 2009
03:29 PM EST
Unfortunately, all these things: wars, recessions, new polices are not new to this country. Like I said, it's unfortunate but these will always be a part of history and our future. The point to remember is that all things improve. Definitley not overnight and not by one single person; as past has proven. I feel Bush is unfairly attacked. After all, WE voted for him for two terms (I know, not by popular vote). As with Obama, all burdens carry over. Bush endured many major castastrophe's; that not just he himself made the decisions on. His staff AND yes even all us Americans. I hope you find peace in his message: "we haven't been attacked since 9/11."

N.Lowell
Jan. 27, 2009
03:28 PM EST
I, like everyone else became disillusioned with President Bush,. However; one must not lay all the blame entirely on him. I for one beleive he had a bunch of holligans for advisors, and had he cleaned house four years ago, his reputation would not be at such an all time low now. One must also remember his actions on 9/11 and afterward--there was som ething to admire there. NJL

Sam Holder
Jan. 27, 2009
06:21 PM EST
@ Long Standing Bear Chief: Indeed--it's already beginning. Karl Rove was subpoenaed yesterday to Congress.

Sam Holder
Jan. 27, 2009
06:28 PM EST
@ richard hummel: Did he really? 2700 Americans died on 9/11. 4,000 (and counting) since the attack...

grace
Jan. 27, 2009
06:27 PM EST
I believe Bush is a good moral man who made mistakes like you and I. History will tell the story, not current hate mail. I also belive he made decisions according to his conscience, not public opinion, and I applaud him for that.

Rafael A. Sanchez
Jan. 27, 2009
06:24 PM EST
Mr. Bush left us a disaster to work with, and the whole wide world knows about it, I just hope that him and members of his staff some day will be prosecuted for the atrocities committed against humans and look forward towards having Mr. Holder pay carefull attention to this matter in order to preserve President Obama's image and not convert him into an accessory to the facts.

bbdj
Jan. 27, 2009
05:33 PM EST
i disagree that if obama fails bush fails but if obama succeeds it still means bush fails because then it proves he really made a mess of the world but had no ideas on how to fix it--only obama had the ideas. either way bush is a disgusting failure who should hold his head in shame. and i wouldn't be surprised if one day we find out bush was complicit in the 9/11 attacks in some way.

Sam Holder
Jan. 27, 2009
06:38 PM EST
@ N.Lowell: I agree about his administration; he perpetuated a culture of yesism.

Sam Holder
Jan. 27, 2009
06:39 PM EST
@ Susan : I don't think American soldiers would find peace in that message.

Sam Holder
Jan. 27, 2009
06:41 PM EST
@ Jeff Levin: Agreed. The second tranche of TARP must be micromanaged.

Flowers
Jan. 27, 2009
09:22 PM EST
Sam: I disagree, I believe American soliders should. After all, it is truly the soliders who are keeping us safe. They are doing what they do best: Fighting for AMERICA! I know we do not want them in harms way, and we most definitley want them ALL back in one piece. I think it is the American way to blame those at the top, and those below should hold no consequences.It's disturbing! We are all in this together, including who we choose as President.

romero rodriguez
Jan. 27, 2009
09:02 PM EST
I don't there is any connection with the terrible administation headed by George Bush, but I agree he will go down in history as the worst ever. Obama has to suceed for two reasons one is god help if dosen,t suceed, and two, hes has small shoes to fill.

lovelyrics
Jan. 27, 2009
06:53 PM EST
I think Bush will be remembered in history as the president who left the worst legacy ever. It has been characteristic for outgoing presidents to leave a mess for the incoming administration to clean up but Bush didn't even have to try! Obama, hopefully, will do the best he can with the good people he has surrounded himself by. The country is ready for change and therefore is likely to give Obama a chance if things don't straighten up right away. (We had Bush for governor here in Texas and the best thing he did was dodge a dump truck that tried to run over him on the Hike and Bike trails!)

Sam Holder
Jan. 27, 2009
11:02 PM EST
@ Flowers: Well, perhaps they "should" feel comfortable, but do they? I encourage you to take a look at these first-hand accounts: http://www.thenation.com/doc/20070101/cooperweb

James Arlan Chantrill
Jan. 28, 2009
11:51 AM EST
President Bush the worst President in US History? Under what moral authority? President Jackson moved the Five Tribes killing thousands of original American citizens. President FD Roosevelt imprisoned thousands of patriotic American citizens. Washington, Jefferson, Madison, Monroe, and others owned slaves. The Iraq war was won with Prsident Saddam Hussein defeated and eventually killed. We were not supposed to make their government. As far as our own government he was inept with his big spending policies, but I hardly believes that that makes the worst president.

Keith
Jan. 28, 2009
10:19 AM EST
I think the left wing and most of the democratic party are the biggest collection of cry babies and phoneys in the world today.

GW did NOT steal an election. Dems failed to win and bitched and moaned for 8 years.
I am sure President Bush never forsaw 9/11 any more than any of the rest of us did. It was largely a result of an across the board attitude of it CAN"T happen here. The liberal dismantlong of the CIA and the WALL of seperation erected between it and the FBI figures LARGE in 9/11 as does the liberal amnesia regarding the first WTC bombing and Clintons ineffectual handling of the Terror that occured on his watch. The handling of the wars etc. had WIDE bi-partisan support.
So if it was a mistake (I don't think it was) it was a universal mistake. Likewise the Patriot act...WIDE bi-lateral support. I think some of it was an overreaction but then that is what politicians do in this country. largely because of the liberal influence we have a nanny state..and that will prove costly on its own terms. Government does NOTHING efficiently. If you think Social security is s good deal and medicare works and FEMA is your saviour you have only to wait till the next crunch. This country made itself with self reliance and grit and hard work...Sittong back in your Lazyboy while Uncle Sam fixes things is a sure loser of a behavior. I thoink Bush will look like a genius after all is said and done.

Good luck to Barrack I hope he does better than I believe he will......I wouldn't count on it.

observer
Jan. 28, 2009
01:53 AM EST
I agree with you article. It is the best way for Bush and Obahma and for our country.

Salem
Jan. 28, 2009
02:22 PM EST
This country made itself with self reliance and grit and hard work. It's a great nation and on it will continue. all what it needs that the great americans should exert all efforts to stand up again and remember alawys that America has helped Europe to get up on its feet, after they lost everything after second world war. america needs all american efforts and President Obama needs us all to clean up after the worst administration ever.

jerry manasco
Jan. 28, 2009
04:24 PM EST
How can we tell one party from the other? both want to play the blame game.Both partys spend with out reflection with out thought with out regret. The only diffrance between the two partys seems to be who can spend are money first and the fastist.Wake up bush haters wake up obama haters please before its to late. P.S.Has anyone looked into the MOTION TO RECOMMIT? This is bad guys this isnt for us. WHAT HAVE WE DONE TO MY AMERICA?

joe lente
Jan. 28, 2009
02:57 PM EST
i think the bush administration did more damage to our country and rights than any previous. i think if obahma was a stand-up guy he would investigate the bush adm and charge as needed but that won't happen, they are all agaINST THE AMERICAN PEOPLE AND I THINK THE END OF THIS ONCE GREAT COUNTRY IS NEAR. if you believe all the propaganda and bs they feed us you're nuts! people in this country need to wake -up and smell what's cooking and it ain't GOOD.

2falloffdBerlinWall
Jan. 28, 2009
08:20 PM EST
Bush was merely a pawn in a scheme run by ex exxon mobile and car company execs. He was the scapegoat for all the problems caused that ran this country (not to mention Iraq and Afghanistan)into the ground, while they lined their pockets. However Obama's recent executive order that refuses lobbyists to bribe congressmen and women (or 'accept gifts'), and disallows them to be hired for issues they lobbied for-is definitely a step in the right direction.
So, Bush's legacy will be one of manipulation and corruption and lies that will take centuries to uncover. Perhaps instead of blaming him we could demand a revamping of the whole system?

SAJ
Jan. 29, 2009
08:12 PM EST
We should put term limits of 8 years on senators and congress. Bush did the best he could. He did want to keep our country safe.
I hope Obama does not try to put in National Health Care, that we DO NOT NEED.
PS I like to listen to Rush L.

Debra
Feb. 03, 2009
03:42 AM EST
I'm so glad to see Bush go, he was an evil evil man, I believe he put this country in such a sad state on purpose. None of them care for the elder or disabled, or our soldier's. It's all about them. Let them live on what some of us do, and the way we do for 4 yr's.Now that's a reality show. I really hope Obama makes a good change for our country, but can't do it alone, it's time we all stepped up and took back some of our rights, and help him make the change. For freedom again, our constituion, our beliefs. Our Values for the things in life that mean something. Back to the simple life, where you knew your neighbor, smiled @ them, had respect for each other, and our belongings. Put a higher power back in place, and take back our Children. We all bleed the same color. Quit letting the Gov. and the media keep us in fear, with their scare tactic's. Red, White, Blue, these color's don't run or burn. Keep involved in your life, your childrens lives and our Gov.

johnaustin
Feb. 06, 2009
01:26 PM EST
George Bush was never an Evil Man...

President Bush is a Methodist and has been very open about the role of faith in his life. Below are selections from recent speeches and interviews in which he mentions his faith or religious topics.

On God, War, and Freedom
"Freedom is on the march in this world. I believe everybody in the Middle East desires to live in freedom. I believe women in the Middle East want to live in a free society. I believe mothers and fathers want to raise their children in a free and peaceful world. I believe all these things, because freedom is not America's gift to the world, freedom is the almighty God's gift to each man and woman in this world."
--Speech in Pennsylvania, October 22, 2004

"...The God I know is one that promotes peace and freedom. But I get great sustenance from my personal relationship. That doesn't make me think I'm a better person than you are, by the way. Because one of the great admonitions in the Good Book is, don't try to take a speck out of your eye if I've got a log in my own."
--Interview by Radio and Television Ireland, June 24, 2004

"I believe that God has planted in every human heart the desire to live in freedom. And even when that desire is crushed by tyranny for decades, it will rise again."
--State of the Union Address, January 20, 2004

"The cause we serve is right, because it is the cause of all mankind. The momentum of freedom in our world is unmistakable--and it is not carried forward by our power alone. We can trust in that greater power who guides the unfolding of the years. And in all that is to come, we can know that His purposes are just and true."
--State of the Union Address, January 20, 2004

Robert Evans
Feb. 13, 2009
07:49 PM EST
On Jay Leno last night, they had a fictional match between Obama, Bush, and McCain. When Obama took time to thank the American voters for his election, Bush piped up and said that he gets plenty of the credit, too. As a Democratic friend in Texas wrote me on her Christmas letter, Now we got Obama in the White House. He now is faced with the mess that Bush and his cronies have left us and the world.

BUCK50 RAHMIER
Jun. 26, 2009
11:15 AM EDT
Obama has done more for this country in 5 months than BUSH has done in 8 years. Bush was only concerned with his pockets and his oil investment. War in IRAQ was great for his family business. In my opinion BUSH was the largest terrorist ever. No president has been responsible for the death of more American citizens since the Vietnam war. You cant fight terror with terror. In the meanwhile our country was plunging into the ground and getting attacked while hes reading a nursery rhyme book and playing golf! How do you get caught cheating in the election and still become President anyway? So what we havent been attacked since 911 when you were the cause of 911. Who cares about his historical future. Obama is for America and he has alot of mess to clean up before he can even get into doing what he has planned for the country. Its not about Black or white, democrat or republican. Its about the land of the free,home of the brave! Put BUSH in the projects of the urban ghetto for 30 days and see how life is there. Dont worry OBAMA will save em with extended food stamps, an extension on his unemployment and better medicaid benefits. Keep taking care of home OBAMA, WE LOVE YOU! ITS TIME FOR CHANGE. BUCK50 RAHMIER

WWWF
Jun. 30, 2009
12:15 PM EDT
George is exactly what he was meant to be. The last ditch effort to keep control of the country in the hands of white males, regardless how stooopid you are. It has been said that the generation during WW2 was america's greatest generation. And i agree, twas a noble thing they did then at great cost to themselves, for a righteous cause. If this is so, once you reach your greatest height, there is nowhere to go but down. george is just the first example of what genetic regression caused by racism will do. Having lived in this country for 60 years, i was flabbergasted that American's, white in particular, would allow such an obvious idiot to represent them to the world. Being a senior who has searched for work for the last 8 years, i have been constantly turned down for jobs of which i am overqualified, for younger, dumber more obedient workers, those who know nothing of worker's rights, overtime, sick pay, unions and so forth. They don't want older workers influencing this new dumb workforce. This therefore calls for one thing, when you want people who don't know anything, you want generation X, which means unknown. What better way to start than with a fool as ignorant as him, and a natural poster boy for total ignorance. P.S. i still have george bush doormat's available, and george bush targets, (shoes not included.) and george's brain boosting drink NU-kyer Cola.(it's nu-kyer than the rest.) Understand one thing, money runs this country, not the repugnicans, or the demo-cats. When America controlled the wealth like England, they were on top. Now they don't and what you are witnessing is the falling from grace of what could have been the greatest country in the modern world. But now thanks to george and his controllers, america is just like me, in debt to everybody, with no job. T.L.G.Whiteman.

Share your thoughts on the story by adding your comments below. Comments containing profanity, derogatory language, or any form of advertisement will not be approved. Comments will be reviewed by the site's editorial team, so your post may not appear for up to 24 hours. Thank you for your patience.

POST YOUR RESPONSE
 
 
Balance of Power

Track the United States government with updates on the three branches of government.

The Issues